Home News

FAA Ground Stop Shows the Cost of Daytime Work on a 1980 Network

Updated on:

Silhouetted travelers seated inside a dimly lit airport terminal watching a Japan Airlines passenger plane taxi across a sunlit runway outside.

The FAA ground stop on Nov. 13 began when a newly installed router flooded the agency’s network with data, and operators canceled about 12,462 flights, the Federal Aviation Administration said in a public Q&A.

The agency has ruled out a cyberattack based on the evidence so far, which leaves an uncomfortable explanation: routine contractor work, done in the middle of a Friday afternoon, knocked out air traffic control across most of the country. The FAA has already said it will reconsider when it does that work, and it should.

What Caused the FAA Ground Stop

The FAA said the stop began around 3:30 p.m. Eastern time and traffic resumed by 8:15 p.m., roughly four hours and 45 minutes. Legacy equipment became unstable when excess data flooded the FAA’s telecommunications network at about 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds, according to the FAA’s account.

Investigators traced the traffic to two possible sources: a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio site in El Dorado, Arkansas, where network contractor L3Harris had been deploying a new router. The instability started at 17 of the 22 air route traffic control centers, which handle high-altitude traffic, and spread to several approach control facilities.

About 3,500 aircraft were in the air and landed safely. The FAA said not every one of the 12,462 cancellations stemmed directly from the stop. A calculation from the FAA’s figures: the outage hit about 77% of the en route centers, and cancellations averaged more than 2,600 for each hour traffic was halted. “Based on all available evidence, we have no indication that this was a cyberattack or an outside nefarious actor,” the FAA said.

Duffy Points to Routers from 2001

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has not hidden where the problem started. “That was our issue,” Duffy said on Nov. 17, according to a Transportation Department summary of his remarks. He said the router model had been installed 69 times and worked in 68 of them, and that the root cause was still unclear.

Two days earlier, Duffy described the equipment’s age on Sunday news shows. “Those routers were purchased in 2001, they were obsolete in 2006,” he said, adding that “the architecture of our network is from 1980,” according to the department’s transcript excerpt.

The FAA disabled the broadcasting function on the Juniper routers involved and on more than 60 others, and it paused installing them. The agency also said it would reevaluate when it performs maintenance, because this work happened during the day rather than at night.

Air Traffic Control Modernization Money

Duffy has used the outage to press Congress. “I need additional money to do the additional work to keep the airspace safe,” he said on Nov. 15, according to the department. He said the $12.5 billion Congress already provided is fully accounted for and will be deployed by the end of 2028. On Nov. 17 he called that sum a “historic down payment” in later remarks, and the department is asking for $50.1 billion more. A calculation from those figures: the money already approved covers about one-fifth of the combined $62.6 billion.

The best case for the department is that this exact work had been routine. Duffy said L3Harris had done it “thousands of times” in the FAA’s network, and the same router had a near-perfect record. But one site was enough to destabilize 17 control centers, and scheduling the installation for a weekday afternoon turned a single failure into a national shutdown. Moving that work to overnight hours requires no new money from Congress.

Duffy said a new telecommunications system could be ready by the end of 2028 or early 2029 if funding comes through. For now, the routers are at an L3Harris lab in Florida, and the FBI has been asked to help analyze them. “I will most definitely share that with you,” Duffy said of the findings.

Stay on. Stay in it.

The stories, shifts, and moments shaping our world — straight to your inbox.