A federal judge in Massachusetts vacated the Department of Homeland Security’s duration of status rule on Nov. 16, ruling that the four-year limit on student and exchange visitor stays was arbitrary and capricious and contrary to law.
The ruling keeps in place a system that lets international students stay as long as they remain enrolled, which matters to every university that recruits abroad. DHS lost on both the law and the process, and the judge refused the softer remedy the government asked for.
What the Duration of Status Rule Would Have Done
For decades, F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors have been admitted for “duration of status,” meaning the length of their program rather than a fixed date. DHS published a final rule on July 17 replacing that with fixed admission periods tied to program length and capped at four years, with extensions required to stay longer. It also cut the time F-1 students have to prepare to leave after finishing a program or practical training from 60 days to 30.
DHS explained its reasoning in the rule. The department said it “believes that the admission of F, J, and I nonimmigrants for D/S is not appropriate,” and that fixed periods would let immigration officers periodically check compliance. The rule was set to take effect Sept. 15. The scale is large. DHS counted about 1.82 million F-1 admissions and about 514,170 J-1 admissions in fiscal 2024, according to the rule.
Judge Saylor Rejects the Rule on Statute and Process
U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV granted summary judgment to a coalition that includes the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, NAFSA, the American Federation of Teachers and The NewsGuild-CWA. His eight-page memorandum and order found two separate problems.
First, DHS “failed to consider less burdensome alternatives,” including improving SEVIS, the government’s existing student tracking system. Second, the rule conflicts with the federal statute defining student visas. “The statute simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program,” Saylor wrote.
The government argued that SEVIS is a data-reporting system for schools, not a tool for adjudicating status, and asked the judge to send the rule back to DHS without striking it. Saylor declined. “The current regime has existed for decades, and the Final Rule has not gone into effect,” he wrote, before vacating the rule in full.
Students Would Have Carried Most of the Cost
The rule’s own economic analysis estimated annualized costs of $443.1 million to $448.6 million, of which only $119.9 million to $125.1 million falls on U.S. parties, according to the Federal Register text. A calculation from those figures: about 72% to 73% of the cost would have landed on people outside that U.S. category, including the students and exchange visitors themselves.
That number helps explain the ruling. An agency that projects more than $440 million a year in costs, mostly borne by the people it regulates, needs to show it weighed a cheaper fix. The court found DHS did not. “Today’s ruling is a clear and important victory for international students and scholars,”
Miriam Feldblum, president and CEO of the Presidents’ Alliance, said in a statement. AFT President Randi Weingarten said the order “will have resounding impacts for generations of scientists and scholars.” DHS was dismissive. “The performative outrage is incredible,” a DHS spokesperson told Fox News Digital, arguing that critics ignored abuse of the student visa system. The best case for the department is that open-ended admission leaves no scheduled checkpoint, and a fixed term would force a review.
What Comes Next for DHS
DHS had already appealed the judge’s earlier order postponing the rule to the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, and Saylor said that the appeal did not stop him from deciding the merits. The plaintiffs’ case page lists that Sept. 14 order alongside the final ruling. The government can now appeal the final judgment to the same court.



